公告
"Copyright by Elisa English" ** The views expressed are mine only and do NOT represent the views of my employer or anyone else. ** 嚴重聲明: Elisa English 文章版權所有 - 請勿竊取. **沒有得到我 (Elisa English) 的許可不可轉貼我的文章及翻譯。請刪除在您的部落格裡我的所有文章及翻譯, 否則我將採取法律行動。 Legal actions will be taken if copyright infringement is found. ** 勿登廣告或求代寫功課. 歡迎中文留言. 我的答覆一律以英文為主. 但我無法保證何時會回覆,因為我不常登入

The boy who was not - 隱形男孩(守秩序)


Author 法里德.卡拉特巴里(Farideh Khalatbaree)

Illustrator - 阿里‧南慕法(Ali Namvar)

 

This was a book about a naughty boy made invisible for disturbing the peace.  I read this book to my son yesterday and I was stunned by the message this book is sending to young kids.  I think that the overall theme is okay up to the point that the kid learnt a lesson for misbehaving.  However, in the end, the kid realized that he was actually not invisible after all because he could see the other naughty boy marked with red line on his forehead.  Seeing that boy hurt, crying for help, he went over and comforted him to get a doctor.  Nevertheless, he was punished and made invisible again for helping that boy. 

 

The conclusion sends a wrong message indicating that you should not help those who misbehaved even though they were in trouble.  This is not the right way to teach our kids.  I see no humanity nor sympathy in this book. 

 

** 版權所有 - Elisa

創作者介紹
創作者 elisaenglish 的頭像
elisaenglish

ELISA ENGLISH 英語園地 - 版權所有

elisaenglish 發表在 痞客邦 留言(1) 人氣()


留言列表 (1)

發表留言
  • yun
  • Dear Elisa:
    Thanks for your sharing. It's fun to read your articles.
    I have never read this book, however, I believed it happened. ( Consciously or subconsciously parents did that to their beloved children.) It's great to know a caring person like you. It's great to know your empathy over the strangers. thanks
  • Hi, yun
    You think too noble of me.  I don't know if subconsciously I am like that or not.  But I do believe that authors of children's book have a greater responsibility to ensure that they are not instilling wrong values to the youth. Kids are like a sponge. 
    I bought this book online believing that it is teaching kids to behave.  Next time, I need to be more careful about online orders.

    elisaenglish 於 2009/01/28 15:24 回覆